|
StarLink is the name of a variety of genetically
engineered (GE) corn that produces it own form of pesticide. Although
the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has approved its use in animal
feed, StarLink has not been approved for human consumption because
it might cause allergic reactions in some people.
StarLink corn has, however, found its way
into the human food chain. In September, 2000, traces of StarLink
were detected in taco shells and breakfast cereals. These products
were recalled from grocery store shelves. In an effort to protect
themselves from further losses, some producers of corn products
stopped using yellow corn, of which StarLink is one variety, and
began using only white corn instead. In July, 2001, the media reported
that the StarLink gene was being detected in white corn as well.
Whether or not StarLink corn actually causes
allergic reactions is irrelevant. What matters is that the potential
allergen has evaded the safeguards that were meant to control it.
The Potential for Food
Allergies
A food allergy, or hypersensitivity, is an abnormal response triggered
by the immune system. The problem may be inherited, or it may develop
at some point in a persons life. In either case, the allergic
response comes after repeated exposure to problematic food. Symptoms
may include itching in the mouth, difficulty breathing, and/or abdominal
pain.
The First Test
After Starlink corn was detected in human food, the Center for Disease
Control (CDC) received 51 reports from people who believed that
they had had an allergic reaction to foods containing the bioengineered
corn. On closer examination, 23 of those reports were discarded
as not fitting the definition of food allergy. Of the 28 candidates
who qualified as having an allergic reaction, 17 agreed to provide
a blood sample.
Preliminary tests run by the CDC did not identify
StarLink as the probable cause of the allergic reactions.
Applying Critical Thinking
Skills
If the CDC did not find a direct correlation between StarLink corn
and the reported allergic reactions, should the FDA retroactively
approve small amounts of StarLink corn in human food, as its developer,
Aventis Crop Sciences, has requested?
For the concerned consumer, the answer is
"no." Consider these issues:
| |
The sample group was 17 people.
This number is statistically insignificant considering the billions
of people who might be exposed to the allergen. |
| |
Food allergies develop after
foods are frequently eaten. Corn, in its many forms, is a very
common food. |
| |
Food allergies are treated
by dietary avoidance. Until GE foods are labeled, consumers
will not have reliable means to avoid the offending food. |
| |
Scientists are still discovering
how to conduct tests for possible food reactions from GE foods. |
The Importance of Labeling
The spread of StarLink corn is cause for concern
among consumers who, due to food intolerances or other health concerns,
do not want to eat genetically engineered food. The current situation
underscores the importance of labeling GE material, whether
in the form of seed, crop, or food products that are presented to
consumers.
|